Haunted Atlantic Waters: The Historic Traumas of Impressment, Slavery, and Whaling in Elizabeth Gaskell's Sylvia's Lovers

Authors

  • Deborah Denenholz Morse College of William and Mary

Abstract

Keywords: Elizabeth Gaskell, Sylvia's Lovers, whaling, impressment, slavery, American Civil War

Gaskell’s choice of the important Yorkshire whaling port of Whitby (the novel’s Monkshaven) as the setting of Sylvia’s Lovers has a deep resonance. The Atlantic Ocean itself, so pervasively described in the novel as the primary element of Monkshaven’s atmosphere, is crucial to interpreting Sylvia’s Lovers as a novel of social protest. In Gaskell’s narrative, the Atlantic’s waters carry off impressed sailors during the early years of the Napoleonic Wars and are the killing grounds for whales in a brutal extraction ecology. The years in which Gaskell wrote her novel—during the American Civil War—evoke a third history throughout Sylvia’s Lovers: the horrific Atlantic slave trade and ongoing American slavery. Gaskell’s choice of Yorkshire as her setting, influenced by her recent writing of The Life of Charlotte Brontë, also suggests that Gaskell was thinking of British West Indian enslavement as well, a consistent background to the Brontë sisters’ novels from Emily’s Wuthering Heights to Charlotte’s Jane Eyre and Anne’s The Tenant of Wildfell Hall. The pervading Atlantic waters in Sylvia’s Lovers are haunted with these brutal histories of violent displacement and bloody carnage. The novel is thus not only the “saddest story I ever wrote,” as Gaskell stated, but also the most harrowing, with its insistent representation or allusion to three interwoven historic traumas against which the individual tragedies of Sylvia’s Lovers are enacted. Gaskell’s Atlantic imaginary is imbued with these histories of violent displacement from family, community, and natural environment, whether impressed sailor, enslaved black American, or harpooned and dismembered whale, its skeletal “great ghastly whale jaws, bleached bare and white . . . the arches over the gateposts to many a field or moorland stretch” disfiguring the landscape and haunting the narrative. Sylvia’s Lovers is an expansive and trenchant novel of social protest against all of these oppressions.

Author Biography

  • Deborah Denenholz Morse, College of William and Mary

    The inaugural Sara E. Nance Eminent Professor of English at William & Mary from 2017-22, Deborah Denenholz Morse was designated a Plumeri Faculty Excellence Scholar a second time for the years 2022-24. On the heels of her first set of lectures for The Great Courses, The Brontës: Romantic Passion and Social Justice (Audible, 2021), she is continuing her publicly engaged scholarship in a second series, entitled “Victorian Animals: Social Critique from Black Beauty to ‘The Owl and the Pussycat’” (forthcoming 2024). She is best known for her scholarship on the Brontës, Anthony Trollope, Elizabeth Gaskell, and in animal studies. She is currently co-editing The MLA Approaches to Teaching Elizabeth Gaskell (with Deirdre d’Albertis). Deborah’s newest project on contemporary Yorkshire writer Pat Barker continues her extensive feminist scholarship on twentieth- and twenty-first-century women writers from Kay Boyle to A.S. Byatt.

References

Works Cited

Anon. Bristol Museums website. https://collections.bristolmuseums.org.uk/stories/transatlantic-traffic-enslaved-africans/#:~:text=By%20the%20late%201730s%20Bristol,British%20Caribbean%20and%20North%

America.&text=By%20the%20latter%20half%20of,had%20been%20over

Anon. “Whale Oil and the Textile Trade.”

https://www.scran.ac.uk/packs/exhibitions/learning_materials/webs/40/jute.htm

Anon. The Whitby Guide. https://www.thewhitbyguide.co.uk/whaling-in-whitby/.

Beaumont, Matthew. “Heathcliff’s Great Hunger: The Cannibal Other in Wuthering Heights.”

Journal of Victorian Culture 9.2 (January 2004): 37–63.

https://doi.org/10.3366/jvc.2004.9.2.137.

Bonaparte, Felicia. The Gypsy Bachelor of Manchester: The Life of Mrs. Gaskell’s Demon.

Charlottesville: U of Virginia P, 1992.

Brunsman, Denver. The Evil Necessity: Naval Impressment in the Eighteenth-Century Atlantic

World. Charlottesville: U of Virginia P, 2013.

D’Albertis, Deirdre. Dissembling Fictions: Elizabeth Gaskell and the Victorian Social Text. New

York: St. Martin’s Press, 1997.

Easson, Angus. “Getting it right: Elizabeth Gaskell and The Life of Charlotte Bronte.” The

Gaskell Society Journal 11 (1997): 1-14.

Ellin, Beth. https://www.visitwhitby.com/blog/whitbys-whaling-history/

Flint, Kate. Elizabeth Gaskell. Plymouth: Northcote House Publishers, 1995.

Foster, Frances Smith and Richard Yarborough, Eds. Introduction. Harriet Jacobs, Incidents in

the Life of a Slave Girl. New York and London: W. W. Norton & Company, 2019.

Gaskell, Elizabeth. North and South. Ed. & Introduction by Patricia Ingham. London: Penguin,

______. Sylvia’s Lovers. Ed. & Introduction by Andrew Sanders. Oxford: Oxford UP, 1999.

Greenwood, John. “‘Our Happy Days in Rome’: The Gaskell-Norton Correspondence.” The

Gaskell Society Journal 28 (2014): 97-104.

Heywood, Christopher. “Yorkshire Slavery in Wuthering Heights.” Review of English Studies 38,

no. 150 (May 1987): 184-98.

Hoare, Philip. Leviathan or, The Whale. London: Fourth Estate/Harper Collins, 2009.

Jackson, Gordon. The British Whaling Trade. Liverpool: Liverpool UP, 2005.

Keegan, John. Battle at Sea: From Man-of-War to Submarine. London: Pimlico, 2004.

King, Richard J. Ahab’s Rolling Sea: A Natural History of Moby-Dick. Chicago and London:

U of Chicago P, 2019.

Lawson, Benjamin S. “From Moby-Dick to Billy Budd: Elizabeth Gaskell’s Sylvia’s Lovers.”

South Atlantic Review 64. 2 (Spring 1999): 37-57.

Lee, Julia Sun-Joo. The American Slave Narrative and the Victorian Novel. Oxford & New York:

Oxford UP, 2010.

McNamara, Robert. "A Brief History of Whaling." ThoughtCo, Apr. 5, 2023, thoughtco.com/a-brief-history-of-whaling-1774068.

Meyer, Susan. Imperialism at Home: Race and Victorian Women’s Fiction. Ithaca: Cornell

UP, 1996.

Morse, Deborah Denenholz. “Burning Art and Political Resistance: Anne Brontë’s Radical

Imaginary of Wives, Slaves, and Animals in The Tenant of Wildfell Hall.” The Brontës

and the Idea of the Human: Science, Ethics, and the Imagination. Ed. Alexandra Lewis. Cambridge UP, 2019. 110-126.

______. “Emily Brontë and the Visual Imagination.” The Edinburgh Companion to the Brontës

and the Arts. With Lydia Brown. Ed. Amber Regis and Deborah Wynne. Forthcoming

June 2024.

______. “Haunting Memories of the English Civil War in Elizabeth Gaskell’s Morton Hall and

Lois the Witch.” Bicentenary issue, The Gaskell Society Journal. Ed. Fran Twinn. 24

(2010): 85-99.

_____. “‘The House of Trauma’: The Influence of Frederick Douglass on Heathcliff in Emily

Brontë’s Wuthering Heights.” Victorians: A Journal of Culture and Literature. Special

Issue on Reconsidering Victorian Domestic Work and Its Narratives. Ed. Tamara

Wagner. No. 140 (December 2021): 164-77.

_____. “Mutiny on the Orion: The Legacy of the Hermione Mutiny and the Politics of

Nonviolent Protest in Elizabeth Gaskell’s North and South.” Pirates and

Mutineers of the Nineteenth Century. Ed. Grace Moore. London: Routledge, 2011.

-33.

_____. “My Lady Ludlow.” The Facts on File Companion to the English

Short Story. Ed. Andrew Maunder. New York. Facts on File, Inc. March 2007. 301-303.

_____. “Stitching Repentance, Sewing Rebellion: Seamstresses and Fallen Women in

Elizabeth Gaskell’s Fiction.” Keeping the Victorian House. Ed. Vanessa Dickerson.

Independence, Kentucky: Garland Press, 1995. 27-73.

Miller, Elizabeth. Extraction Ecologies and the Literature of the Long Exhaustion. Princeton:

Princeton UP, 2021.

O’Gorman, Francis, Introduction. Elizabeth Gaskell, Sylvia’s Lovers. Oxford: Oxford UP, 2014.

ix-xxvi.

Palmer, Aaron J. “An Empire of Liberty’s Evil Necessity.” Review of Denver Brunsman, The

Evil Necessity: British Naval Impressment in the Eighteenth-Century Atlantic World. The

Eighteenth Century 58.2 (Summer 2017): 265-70.

Pettitt, Clare. “Time Lag and Elizabeth Gaskell’s Transatlantic Imagination.” Victorian Studies

4 (Summer 2012): 599-623.

Sanders, Andrew. Introduction. Elizabeth Gaskell, Sylvia’s Lovers. Oxford: Oxford UP, 1982. ii-xvi.

Sdegno, Emma. “Philip Hepburn, Stephen Freeman, and the American Context of Sylvia’s

Lovers.” Annali di Ca’ Foscari. Serie occidentale. Vol. 57 — Settembre 2023.

Shaw, Amber. “‘There Are Two Views Often’: The Epistolary Friendship of Harriet Beecher

Stowe and Elizabeth Gaskell.” Women’s Studies 56 (2022): 682-98.

Shaw, Marion. “Sylvia’s Lovers Then and Now.” The Gaskell Society Journal 18 (2004): 37-49.

Stevens, Nell. Mrs. Gaskell & Me: Two Women, Two Love Stories, Two Centuries Apart.

London: Picador, 2018.

Stoneman, Patsy. Elizabeth Gaskell. Bloomington: Indiana UP, 1987.

Thomas, Hugh. The Slave Trade: The Story of the Atlantic Slave Trade, 1440-1870. New York:

Simon & Schuster, 1999.

Thomas, Sue. Imperialism, Reform, and the Making of Englishness in Jane Eyre. London:

Palgrave Macmillan, 2008.

Twinn, Fran. “Navigational Pitfalls and Topographical Constraints in Sylvia’s Lovers.” The

Gaskell Society Journal 15 (2001): 38-52.

Uglow, Jenny. Elizabeth Gaskell: A Habit of Stories. London: Faber & Faber, 1999.

Von Schneidern, Maja-Lisa. “Wuthering Heights and the Liverpool Slave Trade.” ELH 62.1

(1995): 171-96.

Weyant, Nancy. “Chronology.” Cambridge Companion to Elizabeth Gaskell. Ed. Jill Matus.

Cambridge UP, 2007. xi–xx.

Wright, Terence. Elizabeth Gaskell,‘We Are Not Angels’: Realism, Gender, Values. Basingstoke,

Hampshire and New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 1995.

Downloads

Published

2023-12-06

Issue

Section

Special Issue on 'Water'